Monday, February 23, 2015
Having now had a chance to talk to one of the chicks involved in the experiment, some doubts have been raised in my mind.
The experiment, as you will doubtless recall, involved training a chick to walk around a panel with a number of spots on it in order to receive a reward of food.
When the chick had learnt to do this, it was given the choice of two panels, one on its left and one on its right.
The number of spots on each of these panels was the same but it was a different number from the panel in the training session.
What the researchers found was that if the number was smaller than in training, the chick headed for the one on the left but if it was larger it chose the right-hand one.
So does this, I asked the chick, show that chickens count from left to right, just like humans?
“Well what do you think?” she said.
“It seems to me to be pretty conclusive,” I said.
"I believe that 70 per cent of chicks followed the pattern of going left for small numbers and right for large ones.”
“Would you have done that?” she asked.
“Hmm,” I hmmed.
“Interesting question. I don’t know.”
“Exactly,” said the chick.
“I didn’t know either.
"So I went for the panel that I thought was more likely to result in my being rewarded with food.”
“Well how did you choose?” I asked.
“Simple,” the chick said.
“I found out all I could about the researchers and their previous work, knew that they were working on the idea of a Mental Number Line, discovered that you humans think of numbers from left-to-right, so concluded that they were more likely to reward me for doing the same and going left for small numbers and right for large ones.”
I thought the Greek finance minister denied that he was using Game Theory
“I see,” I said.
“So you weren’t so much following your natural inclination as guessing how the experimenters’ minds worked and trying to do what they hoped for?”
“Exactly,” she said.
“It’s a bit like the Greek debt crisis.”
“Sorry,” I said, “I’m afraid you’ve lost me there.
"What does it have to do with the Greek debt crisis?”
“Well it’s all Game Theory isn’t it?” she said.
“I mean, the choices made by the Greek finance minister and the European Union depend on their assessments of what the other side is going to do.
"It’s a classic game of bluff and counter-bluff.
"In our experiment, however, there was clearly one course of action that was optimal for both sides, so that’s what we went for.”
“Hang on,” I said, “I thought the Greek finance minister denied that he was using Game Theory.”
“It’s all part of Game Theory to deny it,” the chick said.
“If your opponent knows what rules you’re playing under, then it’s all over.
"Anyway, Game Theory assumes that the players are behaving rationally and politicians rarely do that.
"Psychologists are much easier to predict, you know.”
I nodded and we left it at that.
inuLPoker mp4
Blog Archive
-
▼
2015
(639)
-
▼
February
(525)
- Dear boy, I'm the world's biggest fraud: CRAIG BRO...
- Which unnamed soprano murdered Noel Coward's tropi...
- CRAIG BROWN takes trip to fictitional seaside home...
- Ask Lord Prescott... as told to CRAIG BROWN
- Should re-selling website sell primary tickets tha...
- CRAIG BROWN: Who's evil? God, the Archbishop of Ca...
- CRAIG BROWN lists our leaders' ten most interestin...
- How can we find 'inner peace' with HMRC when we're...
- Palestine and Israel unite...against Blair!
- CRAIG BROWN offers a compendium of comforting head...
- CRAIG BROWN: Anyone fancy a nice game of bash a ba...
- TARA EVANS: Unemployed 18-year-old applies for £30...
- CRAIG BROWN: Please Yoko Ono, stop ruining my brea...
- CRAIG BROWN: My top tip for Andy Murray... if you ...
- Nigel Farage answers all of your questions about C...
- CRAIG BROWN: The overacting in The Theory of Every...
- COMMENT: Payday lending problems need urgent atten...
- CRAIG BROWN'S cut out and keep guide to films that...
- CRAIG BROWN: Would Anne Boleyn really use an iPod?...
- And the best labrador in a leading role is...
- CRAIG BROWN: Why I hope Johnny Depp's mustachioed ...
- Excuse me - which way to get lost? A muddled CRAIG...
- CRAIG BROWN: Mellor's next flap? Picking on a peng...
- CRAIG BROWN: Enjoying your birthday? How very un-B...
- Are Ticketmaster's paperless tickets really a bad ...
- Flipping Brilliant! Visit Gran Canaria to get up c...
- Wahey days on the bay! Travel to north Devon for a...
- Reets & wrongs: Who frocked-out on the red carpet ...
- Snow blinder! Alpine resort is a sporting idyll pa...
- BRIT Awards 2015: We head to the backstage spa to ...
- Get her on the catwalk! Stylish Frankie Bridge lea...
- Topshop FROW's sexiest outfits: Kendal Jenner and ...
- Oscars 2015: Get gorgeous Hollywood hair like Jenn...
- Fame Of Thrones: Visit the Croatian city that has ...
- She's just like us! Kim Kardashian reveals she onl...
- Technicolour dream! Moroccan bound for magic trip ...
- High life: Take it to the limit in terrific Toronto
- This is an ICE spot! Les Contamines-Montjoie is th...
- Best of the breast! Holly Willoughby is the cleava...
- Cold Comforts: The best winter holiday destinations
- Zip-zip hooray! Live the high life in a village th...
- Cotton on to this! DJ Fearne rocks new fashion ran...
- Top notch! CRANE transformed into luxury hotel wit...
- From THAT Union Jack pant-exposing dress to Kylie'...
- Made in Chelsea's Rosie Fortescue calls for BAN on...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Reckless by name... Has he handed E...
- 'Watch out Ed Miliband! Your tax triumph might bit...
- JAMES FORSYTH: The Yanks are coming - but are they...
- 'Poor Ed Miliband - even his friends call him a ba...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Why Labour can't wait to be wiped o...
- Silence because it is Dave biggest immigration gam...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Who'll run Britain after the Electi...
- JAMES FORSYTH: David Cameron and the election debates
- JAMES FORSYTH: Why HALF of Ed's MPs have already t...
- JAMES FORSYTH: If Mariupol falls, we could end up ...
- How long will it take to win the Election? Just 10...
- JAMES FORSYTH: George Osborne cuts, Ed Miliband th...
- JAMES FORSYTH: The keys to a Tory win? Fattened pi...
- How a secret Tory pact has stopped the big beasts ...
- JAMES FORSYTH: May's out in front - so they'll sho...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Ed WILL survive... because no one e...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Dave's ready to 'do a Thatcher' on ...
- No, it's not the economy, stupid. It's immigration...
- JAMES FORSYTH: A nation's future... in the hands o...
- Broadchurch FINAL episode: Joe Miller - 'I felt li...
- Dirty Den on Coronation Street? Eastenders Leslie ...
- 'Is this a joke?' Reaction mixed as Broadchurch re...
- EXCLUSIVE: Casual Vacancy village claim 'political...
- 'It was like a car crash' EastEnders' Jo Joyner ad...
- Identity of Deal Or No Deal banker FINALLY revealed
- Game of Thrones Season 4 becomes fastest-selling b...
- WATCH: Tense new House of Cards trailer for season...
- TV round-up: Indian Summers, EastEnders, Wolf Hall...
- SPOILER: EastEnders' Peter and Lauren visit Lucy's...
- 98 years old and STILL as piscatorial as ever…
- 98 years old and STILL horrified by soap…
- 98 years old and STILL having a busy week
- 98 years old and STILL checking checkouts out…
- 98 years old and STILL plays games with chicks…
- 98 years old and STILL punctilliously punctuated
- 98 years old and STILL on a great Odyssey
- 98 years old and STILL longing for tea-time…
- 98 years old and STILL taking one week at a time
- 98 years and STILL blaming chocolate
- 98 years old and STILL counting his chickens
- Justice is not served by the Crown Prosecution Ser...
- Leaders’ TV debate gets ever more silly, blasts AN...
- What happened to the grace and humour which used t...
- Lots of people lack the motivation to cook, slams ...
- Is anybody thinking logically any more?
- Authorities not putting child first, says ANN WIDD...
- Welby’s words were taken out of context, argues AN...
- Bah humbug! Another politically correct year, anot...
- Winston Churchill would get rid of Islamic State a...
- How to tackle New Year, advises ANN WIDDECOMBE
- BBC's Today programme is not a turn-on anymore ¿ i...
- Fair is foul and foul is fair in the world of the ...
- The 'Ugly Sisters' of the teaching unions want to ...
- Teachers are complaining that GCSE English was mar...
- Now is the time to break the stranglehold of the t...
-
▼
February
(525)
0 comments:
Post a Comment