Wednesday, February 18, 2015
Published: 17:45 GMT, 2 August 2012 | Updated: 09:53 GMT, 3 August 2012
Critic: Gore Vidal was scathing about the intellectual capability of modern US politicians
Gore Vidal, the acid-tongued American writer and wit who died this week put it well in his usual waspish way.
Speaking of modern US politicians he said: 'They no longer write their own speeches or books, and there is some evidence that they cannot read them either'.
Where Abraham Lincoln jotted down the immortal words of the Gettysburg address while listening to the interminable speaker who preceded him, Vidal's contemporary President John Kennedy confessed after delivering a keynote speech on agriculture to American farmers that he had not understood a word of what he had been saying. And the book that won JFK a Pulitzer Prize and his first recognition, 'Profiles in Courage', was ghosted for him by Theodore Sorensen, a hero-worshipping Kennedy groupie historian who also wrote Kennedy's speeches. And things have got a whole lot worse since JFK's heyday.
Nor is this increasing idle ignorance confined to American politicians.
Dumb stupidity is the hallmark of our dear leaders on this side of the pond too. Probably our last truly literate leading politician was Roy Jenkins, the son of a Welsh miner who had the airs and graces of a Duke, and wrote elegantly crafted works of political biography. Another Labour politician, Tony Benn, churned out endless Pooterish journals - as did, from either end of the political spectrum, Alan Clark and Chris Mullin - but these gossipy 'Dear Diaries', however entertaining, are hardly great works of political history or literature.
Literate: Roy Jenkins had the airs and graces of a Duke, although he was actually the son of a Welsh minerEdward Heath, the treacherous pseudo-Tory who conned Britain into the EU, did write books it is true. But they were typically ego-maniacal works in praise of his own (highly questionable) skills as an amateur yachtsman and orchestral conductor. Even so, the illiteracy of our current breed of politicians makes Edward Heath look like the great historian Edward Gibbon by comparison. But what else can be expected of wonks with no experience of the world outside the Westminster bubble, who have, like Cameron and Miliband, moved seamlessly from university to political research, to a safe seat and so onto the green benches and (if they are lucky) the black limousines and the red Ministerial boxes.
Alan Clark wrote entertaining, albeit gosspiy, diaries, while Edward Heath should be credited for writing his own booksIt is taken as a matter of course that when a newspaper features an article 'by...some politician ' the statesperson concerned will not have scribbled a word of it. We are in fact conniving in their lies. And the same applies to their 'speeches'. At most they will have cast a languid eye over what some lowly minion - or team of lowly minions - have laboriously knocked out. The collection of cliches and tired, trite empty phrases that passes for political discourse these days will be the result of several meetings of civil servants and SPADS, probably been run past a Focus Group and finally been signed off by the politician whose name will fraudulently appear above it or who will deliver his honeyed words from the speakers' podium. It will certainly be a case of too many cooks spoiling the tepid broth, and will certainly not resemble the polished oratory of a Demosthenes. a Cicero, a Pitt or a Churchill.
Achievement: Winston Churchill churned out multi-volume works of biography and historyBut, as historian David Starkey demonstrates in his current Channel 4 series 'The Churchills', things were very different in Winston's day. In his study of Churchill as a historian, Starkey shows the great man in his wilderness years churning out not only thousands of words of his own journalism, but huge, multi-volume works of biography and history - which after the war won him a Nobel Prize for Literature. It's true that he employed a team of bright young historians as researchers, but the end product, with its peerless prose, was indisputably his.
But even if they are too busy tweeting and appearing on witless TV shows to research and write history, you might hope that the politicians of today would at least read it. Instead, they make a virtue of their profound and shaming ignorance.
Anyone with even the sketchiest knowledge of Middle Eastern history would not have invaded Iraq, as Bush and Blair did. And David Cameron's apparent belief that we were playing second fiddle to the US in 1940, when Britain was actually standing alone against the Nazis demonstrates that while he may hold a degree in PPE (Oxford's equivalent of Media Studies) - his historical knowledge is woefully lacking. The same goes for his sidekick George Osborne's 'Teach Yourself Economics' (yet still get it wrong) - grasp of the financial abyss we are staring into.
Lessons: If modern politicians aren't going to write history, they could at least read itAs they pack for the summer beaches and Tuscany pools, let me implore our leaders to find room in their wheelies for a new slim volume from their colleague Daniel Hannan. 'Unhappy Marriage: Britain & Europe (Notting Hill Editions).
In a little over 100 devastating pages they would learn why the EU is a fundamentally flawed project, why the Euro is doomed and why Britain has no future in such a corrupt and undemocratic body. For the new breed of political, economic and historical illiterates that would at least be a start.
var rcShoutCache = '{}'; window._taboola = window._taboola || []; _taboola.push({flush:true});inuLPoker mp4
Blog Archive
-
▼
2015
(639)
-
▼
February
(525)
- Dear boy, I'm the world's biggest fraud: CRAIG BRO...
- Which unnamed soprano murdered Noel Coward's tropi...
- CRAIG BROWN takes trip to fictitional seaside home...
- Ask Lord Prescott... as told to CRAIG BROWN
- Should re-selling website sell primary tickets tha...
- CRAIG BROWN: Who's evil? God, the Archbishop of Ca...
- CRAIG BROWN lists our leaders' ten most interestin...
- How can we find 'inner peace' with HMRC when we're...
- Palestine and Israel unite...against Blair!
- CRAIG BROWN offers a compendium of comforting head...
- CRAIG BROWN: Anyone fancy a nice game of bash a ba...
- TARA EVANS: Unemployed 18-year-old applies for £30...
- CRAIG BROWN: Please Yoko Ono, stop ruining my brea...
- CRAIG BROWN: My top tip for Andy Murray... if you ...
- Nigel Farage answers all of your questions about C...
- CRAIG BROWN: The overacting in The Theory of Every...
- COMMENT: Payday lending problems need urgent atten...
- CRAIG BROWN'S cut out and keep guide to films that...
- CRAIG BROWN: Would Anne Boleyn really use an iPod?...
- And the best labrador in a leading role is...
- CRAIG BROWN: Why I hope Johnny Depp's mustachioed ...
- Excuse me - which way to get lost? A muddled CRAIG...
- CRAIG BROWN: Mellor's next flap? Picking on a peng...
- CRAIG BROWN: Enjoying your birthday? How very un-B...
- Are Ticketmaster's paperless tickets really a bad ...
- Flipping Brilliant! Visit Gran Canaria to get up c...
- Wahey days on the bay! Travel to north Devon for a...
- Reets & wrongs: Who frocked-out on the red carpet ...
- Snow blinder! Alpine resort is a sporting idyll pa...
- BRIT Awards 2015: We head to the backstage spa to ...
- Get her on the catwalk! Stylish Frankie Bridge lea...
- Topshop FROW's sexiest outfits: Kendal Jenner and ...
- Oscars 2015: Get gorgeous Hollywood hair like Jenn...
- Fame Of Thrones: Visit the Croatian city that has ...
- She's just like us! Kim Kardashian reveals she onl...
- Technicolour dream! Moroccan bound for magic trip ...
- High life: Take it to the limit in terrific Toronto
- This is an ICE spot! Les Contamines-Montjoie is th...
- Best of the breast! Holly Willoughby is the cleava...
- Cold Comforts: The best winter holiday destinations
- Zip-zip hooray! Live the high life in a village th...
- Cotton on to this! DJ Fearne rocks new fashion ran...
- Top notch! CRANE transformed into luxury hotel wit...
- From THAT Union Jack pant-exposing dress to Kylie'...
- Made in Chelsea's Rosie Fortescue calls for BAN on...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Reckless by name... Has he handed E...
- 'Watch out Ed Miliband! Your tax triumph might bit...
- JAMES FORSYTH: The Yanks are coming - but are they...
- 'Poor Ed Miliband - even his friends call him a ba...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Why Labour can't wait to be wiped o...
- Silence because it is Dave biggest immigration gam...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Who'll run Britain after the Electi...
- JAMES FORSYTH: David Cameron and the election debates
- JAMES FORSYTH: Why HALF of Ed's MPs have already t...
- JAMES FORSYTH: If Mariupol falls, we could end up ...
- How long will it take to win the Election? Just 10...
- JAMES FORSYTH: George Osborne cuts, Ed Miliband th...
- JAMES FORSYTH: The keys to a Tory win? Fattened pi...
- How a secret Tory pact has stopped the big beasts ...
- JAMES FORSYTH: May's out in front - so they'll sho...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Ed WILL survive... because no one e...
- JAMES FORSYTH: Dave's ready to 'do a Thatcher' on ...
- No, it's not the economy, stupid. It's immigration...
- JAMES FORSYTH: A nation's future... in the hands o...
- Broadchurch FINAL episode: Joe Miller - 'I felt li...
- Dirty Den on Coronation Street? Eastenders Leslie ...
- 'Is this a joke?' Reaction mixed as Broadchurch re...
- EXCLUSIVE: Casual Vacancy village claim 'political...
- 'It was like a car crash' EastEnders' Jo Joyner ad...
- Identity of Deal Or No Deal banker FINALLY revealed
- Game of Thrones Season 4 becomes fastest-selling b...
- WATCH: Tense new House of Cards trailer for season...
- TV round-up: Indian Summers, EastEnders, Wolf Hall...
- SPOILER: EastEnders' Peter and Lauren visit Lucy's...
- 98 years old and STILL as piscatorial as ever…
- 98 years old and STILL horrified by soap…
- 98 years old and STILL having a busy week
- 98 years old and STILL checking checkouts out…
- 98 years old and STILL plays games with chicks…
- 98 years old and STILL punctilliously punctuated
- 98 years old and STILL on a great Odyssey
- 98 years old and STILL longing for tea-time…
- 98 years old and STILL taking one week at a time
- 98 years and STILL blaming chocolate
- 98 years old and STILL counting his chickens
- Justice is not served by the Crown Prosecution Ser...
- Leaders’ TV debate gets ever more silly, blasts AN...
- What happened to the grace and humour which used t...
- Lots of people lack the motivation to cook, slams ...
- Is anybody thinking logically any more?
- Authorities not putting child first, says ANN WIDD...
- Welby’s words were taken out of context, argues AN...
- Bah humbug! Another politically correct year, anot...
- Winston Churchill would get rid of Islamic State a...
- How to tackle New Year, advises ANN WIDDECOMBE
- BBC's Today programme is not a turn-on anymore ¿ i...
- Fair is foul and foul is fair in the world of the ...
- The 'Ugly Sisters' of the teaching unions want to ...
- Teachers are complaining that GCSE English was mar...
- Now is the time to break the stranglehold of the t...
-
▼
February
(525)
0 comments:
Post a Comment